So I’ve been working on a list of my 10 favourite Buffy episodes, although as Joss Whedon points out, these sorts of things are constantly in flux. Therefore, I am unwilling to commit and say that these are my 10 favourite episodes of all time, but I do think that most of them are pretty darn awesome. FYI, if you haven’t seen Buffy, you shouldn’t read this post, because you will find it confusing and possibly boring, and also because it will spoil you, which will be a pity when you finally do watch Buffy.
I tried to think of a couple of criteria when narrowing down episodes to add to the list. For one thing, most of my favourite episodes are artistically amazing; there’s innovative use of lighting, music, and staging which really makes them stand out. A lot of them are also important for plot development, in some way or another. And some of them…are just too cool. I know that coolness is kind of a hallmark of the show, but even coolness has its ups and downs, and on occasion things transcend even my imaginative boundaries of coolness.
1. Innocence (Season Two, Episode 14)
This, for me, was the moment when the show really started to prove itself as being about more than just a show with a bad-ass chick and awesome fight scenes, because it was dark, and it was deep, and it was all allegorical and stuff. I think that it also spoke to a very real experience; how many of us have spent a night with someone and then found out that they changed? Granted, becoming an evil vampire may not be something we’ve all experienced, but the sudden shift in the dynamic between two people was very real, and very well done. Also, uhm, evil Angel is just cooler than good Angel. Sorry guys, but it’s true. And you know it.
2. Passion (Season Two, Episode 17)
Ok, this might actually go onto my list of all time favourite episodes, because what Angel does to Jenny is just so brilliantly inspired. I mean, Joss Whedon says “Death, La Boheme, and Tony Head with a flaming baseball bat. Come ON, people.” And he’s right. There’s nothing about this episode that doesn’t rock, and I think it also sets the stage for the various characters and their struggles with redemption and past deeds. As viewers, we know in the abstract that evil Angel is pretty evil, but this really brings it home. And as someone with a finely honed appreciation for vengeance and brilliant staging, I had to love that scene with Giles coming home, the opera on the stereo, the champagne on the table…so beautiful, it brought tears to my eyes.
3. I Only Have Eyes For You (Season Two, Episode 19)
Man, talk about redemption. In addition to just being creepy and wonderful with a dash of gender-bending thrown in, this was all about forgiveness and learning to come to terms with people. I love how Buffy just refuses to emphasize with James, until he possesses her and she really understands what it feels like. In “Earshot” in the next season, this idea kind of gets touched on again, that we really don’t know what’s going on in people’s lives until we stand in their shoes (or their heads) for a moment. I think that’s another really important theme in the show, as well, and I note that three of my favourite episodes are from season two, so obviously they got a lot of setting up, themewise, done this season.
4. Hush (Season Four, Episode 10)
This is often hailed as one of the greatest Buffy episodes ever, because it’s so beautiful, and so experimental, and just so freakin’ awesome you see it and you want to pee your pants. Whedon claims that he did this episode as a personal challenge, to get out of the rut of formulaic dialogue and cinematography, and boy howdy did he get out of the rut. The very idea of an entire town stricken with an inability to speak is so very excellent, and it plays upon the almost constant Buffy theme of a lack of communication. Also, the Gentlemen are seriously, seriously nightmare-inducing creepy.
5. Restless (Season Four, Episode 22)
Talk about arty, and talk about a huge departure from the norm for network television. Instead of ending season four with the big payoff, they went for the surrealistic dream sequence, and they did a freakin’ AMAZING job with it. I love the lighting, I love the scenes, I love the staging, I love the themes, I love the Cheese Man, I love the entire damn thing. I can’t even single out a moment in this episode to point to as the most awesome one, because the whole thing is just so damn wonderful. I mean, Spike and Giles on the swing set in tweed? Buffy in the desert with the first Slayer? Willow running through the, ah, red velvet curtains? Xander in the ice cream truck, crawling around like a soldier? There are so many beautiful moments. It plays with a bunch of themes from the show, it puts people in ludicrous situations, and it takes viewers far beyond their comfort zone. Oh, yes.
6. The Body (Season Five, Episode 16)
The death of Joyce is obviously a cathartic moment in the show, but what I love about this episode is how beautifully it captured the mundane and numbing aspect of grief. The awkwardness of not knowing what to do, of nervous making/eating food, of being unsure about plans. I liked that it encompassed everything about how weird death is, how strange it is that people die, and that it managed to do it brilliantly, with all these harsh camera angles, and the total absence of music, and long, uncomfortable pauses. You watch “The Body” and you wish you were almost anywhere else because it feels so intrusive and violating, but, at the same time, you’re sucked into it. Also, great that they managed to tie in the strange sexuality which surrounds death without making it crude and too obvious.
7. Once More, With Feeling (Season Six, Episode Seven)
It’s a musical. Do I really need to say more? Musical. Buffy. I hate musicals, and I fucking ADORE “Once More, With Feeling,” because it’s funny, and excellent, and while it is the polar opposite of “Hush,” it also has a lot of similarities. I mean, two seasons later, the characters are still struggling to communicate with each other, and all these secrets just come spilling out. Oh, and the cast are pretty darn good singers, too. I mean Tony Head, of course, is a good singer, but I was darn impressed with Amber Benson’s pipes.
Also, did you hear Joss Whedon voicing the “grr, argh” at the end? Priceless.
8. Smashed (Season Seven, Episode Nine)
Uhm, yeah. The scene. In the house. With Spike and Buffy. May be the hottest scene ever broadcast on network television. I mean, HOLY SHIT. Damn. Jesus. I almost need to take a cold shower just thinking about it.
On another note, one thing about the characterization of the relationship between Spike and Buffy really bothers me, and that is the implication that the violent aspects of their relationship are inherently self destructive. Now, that scene in “Seeing Red” with them in the bathroom, that is violent and self destructive and horrible. But there’s nothing wrong with a bit of good, clean roughhousing. And, you know, superheroes would naturally roughhouse a bit more, ah, roughly than the rest of us. There are a lot of things about the relationship that are destructive and unhealthy (like the fact that she tries to hide it from her friends), but I really object to the idea that violent sexuality is necessarily bad. I mean, it’s, uh, obviously consensual, and everyone’s having a good time, so what’s the problem?
9. Normal Again (Season Six, Episode 17)
I love this episode both because it’s delightfully self-referential, and because it toys with the heads of the viewers. I mean, most of the time when you have crazy shows about supernatural happenings with totally unbelievable events, you just accept them, and so do the characters. “Normal Again” turned the entire concept of Buffy on its head by forcing viewers to ask themselves whether or not the story is even real. Is Buffy a superhero, the chosen, the Slayer, or is she just some really messed-up girl in an institution who created a complex fantasy world?
10. Touched (Season Seven, Episode 20)
I find the episodes at the end of the seventh season incredibly heartbreaking and depressing, because there’s something really sad about watching Buffy slowly build up her character over seven years, and then having her life turned upside down. To be betrayed by the people you care most deeply about is a pretty intense thing, and it’s agonizing to watch. The tension at the end of this season just doesn’t let up, either. No happy funtime lightweight episodes to break up the somberness, just straight up unrelenting heartbreak, evil, and skulduggery.
“Touched” shows Buffy at her most human, and most vulnerable, and I find it quite fascinating that she turns to Spike, in the end, when her friends turn on her. I think it really illustrates how the two are really outsiders when it comes down to it, even when she comes back to reunite the gang and gets her friends back. There’s a thread there, that happens in situations like that, and it forges a very strong bond between people, making Spike’s sacrifice in episode 22 all the more sad.