I spent yesterday in a state of bleak fury. The weather reflected my mood, with cold hostile grey clouds and occasional spats of rain. Every now and then, a moment of elation would bubble up, as I remembered that 63,916,185 other Americans voted for hope with me. And then I remembered that 52% of California voters, 57% of Arkansians, 56% of Arizonans, and 62% of Floridians voted for hatred and bigotry, and I got sad and angry again.
I went to Headlands early on Wednesday to pick up the major newspapers. Not because I thought that they would have anything new and different, but because I thought I might like to have them. Even in my bitterness, I knew that this was a historic moment, and that I might like to haul those papers out some day in the future. The coffeehouse was packed to the gills, but totally silent, and it was extremely eerie.
America did a great thing on Tuesday. I don’t think that I really need to belabor that point. I talked to lots of people on Tuesday who were incredibly enthused and excited, including a young friend who became eligible to vote just in time for the election. He was in awe and delight, but at that point, all I could feel was sadness. I am so proud to be an American right now, so amazed with what we just did, and I am so ashamed of being a Californian.
Millions of us learned on Tuesday night that you really can grow up to be anything. And a lot of us learned that we can’t marry the men and women we love. That we can’t adopt children with our partners. That Americans think that we don’t deserve equal protection under the law. That America could simultaneously take a huge leap in the realm of civil rights, and a giant step backwards. That other Americans hate us so much that they will pour millions of dollars into a campaign to take rights away from us. That we are second class citizens, and that a shocking percentage of the population is ok with this, including the people who claim to “support” us.
And I can’t get over that. I’m sorry, I just can’t. I know that I am supposed to be excited, but it’s hard when people dismiss me with “oh, it will get better.” Well, you know what, they didn’t tell Martin Luther King that it would get better. They didn’t tell Elizabeth Cady Stanton that it would get better. They fought, and they won, and we fought, and we won, and someone else voted to take it all away. We were on the front of the bus in California, proudly clutching each other’s hands, and 52% of the people who live in this state voted to throw us off. And the rest of the country watched them do it and took note.
I think that the people I talked to about this issue couldn’t quite wrap their heads around it, for the most part, because they were heterosexual. Oh, sure, they supported freedom to marry, and they cared about it, and they were sad too, but they couldn’t comprehend how much this crushed me and all of the other LGBQT Americans who just got shat upon on Tuesday. They could understand in an abstract way that this was a sad thing, but for the most part, they couldn’t connect with it on a personal level, and they were too excited to try.
Yesterday morning, I understood privilege on a visceral level, because I was finally on the other side of the divide. As a white person in a liberal community who presents female, I really haven’t been the victim of that much discrimination. Sure. I’ve had to deal with things because I am a woman, and some of those things have been pretty crappy, but I’ve never walked down the street feeling like the entire world hates me. Until yesterday.
I found this quote on Jezebel: “If I was gay in America today I would walk out of the door feeling like the whole country was at war with me (and as an African I have had my moments where I know how that feels) and it just breaks my heart that TODAY, TODAY OF ALL DAYS, someone else somewhere has to feel like that.” And I have to say, it made me a little misty around the eyes. Blacks in this country have fought so hard just to be treated like human beings, and they still deal with discrimination on a daily basis, and now I know what that feels like, not in an abstract “wow, the way we have treated blacks is really shitty way,” but in a “I am completely crushed and my heart is broken” kind of way.
We made great steps in the realm of reproductive rights, as a nation, on Tuesday night. Stem cell research got approved, an abortion ban got voted down, a fetal personhood law got soundly spanked, those same Californians who thumbed their noses at us voted down a parental notification law, barely.
I want to be happy for my fellow women, to know that people in red states and blue states both voted “yes” to reproductive rights. I want to be happy for black Americans, because they are living in a historic moment, and it is awesome, it really is, but I’m drinking a bitter cup over here. And other people might not know it yet, but they are too. The decision to deny civil rights to people, to amend the California constitution to take civil rights away, that was a dangerous and terrible thing, and it set a dangerous and terrible precedent. I think it’s something that those people who cheerfully voted “yes” to hate might come to regret later.
This wasn’t about marriage. It was about disenfranchisement, and the willing choice to revoke rights. This was about creating a second class of people. Yes, all things take time, and yes, gay rights take time, and I can’t say that I think that the movement has been perfect, but in this point, I am horrified by this unprecedented event. Never before in history have people voted to take civil rights away. This, people, is why civil rights issues should not be on the ballot. The majority should not be making decisions for the minority.
To put it more simply, in 2000, California passed a ban on gay marriage. In the summer of 2008, that ban was challenged in the court, and the court ruled that under the equal protection clause, that ban was unconstitutional. A majority of Californians just voted to change the Constitution to make it say what they wanted, thereby raising questions about the validity of the equal protection clause, if you can write in exceptions so simply.
Last night, I watched V for Vendetta, which I do every 5 November, to remember what I am fighting for. And when I got to the scene with Valerie Page, I cried. I cried for what we lost, and for what everybody lost without realizing it. I cried because 52% of California voters hate me and people like me so much that they want to tell us how to live.
California, Arkansas, Arizona, and Florida, what you did was wrong. And I hope that you come to see that someday. Barack Obama and Joe Biden, your failure to stand up for civil rights in this historic election was wrong. And don’t think you’re off the hook either, Democratic Party. You sank a lot of money into this election and you gained a lot, but you trampled all over a lot of people in the process.
I saw the faces of 8 supporters at victory rallies, and they were twisted with hatred. It reminded me of those oft-distributed images of parties in the Middle East after 11 September. And it reminded me that we have a long way to go, as a country, if we think it’s acceptable to put morality issues on the ballot, and we think it’s acceptable to rejoice when those ballot measures pass, instead of being ashamed. The only bright spot for LGBQT Americans on Tuesday was in Colorado, where Jared Polis became the first openly gay Congressional Representative from Colorado.
I walked downtown yesterday in the rain and I watched people pass, and I thought “did you vote against me? Did you? How about you?” And I wanted to ask “why? Why would you do something like that? Why would you twist the words of Christ to support hatred and bigotry, why would you rejoice when you crush your neighbors’ souls? How is that Christian? How is that Godly? What is wrong with you?” 37.8% of Mendocino County voted yes on 8. I’ll bet that I know some of those people. They might be my neighbors, my supermarket checkers, the people who drive by while I wait at the light on Laurel in the rain. And they apparently think that I am not a person. Not deserving of the same rights they have.
If you are one of those people who voted yes on anti-gay legislation, and you read this in its entirety instead of clicking away, I have two words for you: fuck you.