Book 121: Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Tuesday, May 6th, 2008After reading The Emperors of Chocolate, I felt like I had to read Charlie, just to balance things out. And because there were several references to this famous Roald Dahl book which whetted my appetite for one of my most favourite books ever.
I’m going to assume that you have read Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, so I don’t need to tell you what happens, nor am I spoiling anything by discussing the plot.
One thing which I really thought about in this reading was all of the lessons embedded in the book. There are definitely some morals about greed and a lust for objects as we see the greedy, consumerist characters contrasted with Charlie. There are also a few oh-so-pleasant anti-fat digs in the book, which I try to overlook in the interest of the fact that the book is otherwise excellent. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory suggests that awesome things can happen to anyone, at any time, and I like that. It also promotes reading over television, charity over selfishness, and other values I am pretty fond of.
I also rethought the Oompa Loompas this time. After all, they are basically illegal immigrants (Wonka talks about shipping them in boxes with airholes drilled in), and they are held prisoner in the factory to work as eternal factory laborers. That’s kind of depressing. I mean, the book portrays them as happy little colored people (which is problematic in and of itself), who volunteer to work at the factory, and are stoked to be there, but I have to wonder. There’s a whiff of white man’s burden that I hadn’t really paid attention to before.
That said, I still really like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, and I’m not going to let PC sensibilities ruin a good book for me. But I can see how people get riled up so easily about books; I’m sure it’s pretty easy to find something objectionable in almost any book. This is one of the reasons I’m not a fan of book banning or the destruction of other works of art on the basis of their aesthetics, because it strikes me as a very slippery slope.
Demographics:
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, by Roald Dahl. Published 1964, 155 pages. Fiction.